Copyright: © 2026 by the authors. Licensee: Pirogov University.
This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (CC BY).

ORIGINAL RESEARCH

The challenges of open science and the emerging roles of research ethics committees

About authors

Institute of Philosophy National Academy of Sciences of Belarus, Belarus

Received: 2026-06-21 Accepted: 2026-07-19 Published online: 2026-11-17
|

For decades, ethics committees (ECs) have served as a cornerstone institution for safeguarding the rights and welfare of biomedical research participants. Their traditional role involves conducting an independent expert review of research projects, weighing scientific merit against potential risks and benefits. They also ensure that participants are properly informed and that the study fully aligns with the core principles of biomedical ethics such as autonomy, non-maleficence, beneficence, and justice [1]. Traditionally, their function is to independently evaluate research proposals by balancing scientific value with risks and benefits, verifying informed consent, and upholding fundamental bioethical principles, namely respect for persons, non-maleficence, beneficence, and justice [1]. Historically, the evolution of ethical review emerged from the global response to misconduct in biomedical research. A major turning point was Declaration of Helsinki of the World Medical Association, which firmly established that the rights and well-being of research participants must always take precedence over the interests of science and society [2,3].

However, as research practices advance, it is clear that the actions of ECs frequently diverge from the goals established in both advisory guidelines and national laws.

As a rule, this is due to the formal nature of reviewing research protocols and the content of informed consents, in attention to the creation and use of databases, insufficient confidentiality protection of research participants, lack of knowledge and skills to conduct legally correct and ethically meaningful expertise, etc. In many cases, ethical control is limited with checking the documents and procedures, whereas a deeper estimation of research context, social significance and potential effects of the project is beyond the interests of EC expertise.

Open science, which is the modern paradigm of science development, significantly alters the parameters and tasks of  research activity and, thus, requires a serious change in how the EC functions. The patterns of openness and accessibility for the society and the use of the AI systems, which is the main tool of open science, are used to transform the architecture of the research process. Thus, the data are available for re-testing increasing their requirements for collection, storage, transparency, reproducibility and control; publications become more dynamic and open; research acquire inter- and transdisciplinary character; the researcher’s responsibility for the results of their research increases; and more attention needs to be paid to the humanization of science and ensuring the safety of humans and nature.

For EC, this necessitates expanding and deepening the scope of their evaluation. Beyond traditional review criteria, they must now assess the use of AI systems in research, analyze the entire data lifecycle including anonymization and storage, emphasize scientific integrity and ethical standards, consider public engagement in research, etc. The value of expertise capable to assess not only separate research, but also the social and digital infrastructure where it is being implemented is growing in importance today.

Interdisciplinary research, which intersects medicine, biostatistics, informatics, sociology, law, ethics, and other scientific fields, presents a particular challenge for the EC. Such projects require different methodological and ethical criteria than traditional clinical studies, as they involve different data handling methods, varying standards of evidence, and different perceptions of acceptable risks. Concurrently, the core values of research practices are shifting, bringing transparency, accountability for algorithmic decisions, equitable access to data and publications, and the ethical verification of scientific knowledge production methods to the forefront.

Modern research ecosystems demand a stronger consultative and educational presence from EC members. Their efforts are now directed toward ongoing collaboration with researchers and society, alongside creating recommendations and guidance tools. To address the issues raised, a reevaluation of the role of ECs is necessary. They should function not merely as regulatory bodies for science, but rather as methodological and value-based navigators [4].

The goal of the research is to identify and characterize new priority areas of activity and roles for EC, emerging in response to the challenges of open science, the integration of AI into research practice, the development of new models of research ethics, and the establishment of interdisciplinary research.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The article was prepared as part of research conducted at the National Academy of Sciences of Belarus (NASB) and the Republican Center on Bioethics (RCB).

We reviewed international and national documents that regulate biomedical ethics, AI applications, data security, and the execution of high-profile research amid heightened uncertainty. Recommendations of the World Health Organization on research ethics, universal ethical standards of research ethics, UNESCO documents on open science and ethics of artificial intelligence, as well as national and regional documents regulating the use of AI in medicine and scientific activities, among others, were analyzed. Additionally, scientific publications, monographs, and analytical materials on bioethics, AI ethics, open science, research integrity, and expert activities of ethics committees in medicine and related fields were explored [5–8].

The empirical basis of this research comprises the outcomes of practical and expert activities, including those derived from the author’s participation in international projects focused on the operation of ethics committees. Specifically, the materials from the international projects “Developing Recommendations for Ethics Committees and Policy Guidance for Eastern European/Central Asian Countries to Support Public Health Emergency Preparedness and Response,” conducted under the auspices of the WHO and implemented in 2020–2021 with the participation of 11 Eastern European and Central Asian countries, and “Mapping Ethics Committee (IEC/IRB) Practices for Engaging Communities in Health Research in Eastern Europe and Central Asian countries,” carried out with WHO support in 2021–2022 with the participation of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Armenia, and Belarus, and dedicated to models of community engagement in tuberculosis research.

Also significant is the participation in an international study by the Research Data Alliance (RDA) as part of the Artificial Intelligence and Data Visitation Working Group (AI&DV WG). This collaboration resulted in the formulation of recommendations for ECs reviewing research AI and data visitation practices within open science [9].

We also relied on data from anonymous pilot surveys conducted in 2023–2025 by the Republican Center on Bioethics as part of an initiative project on the ethics of AI use among representatives of the healthcare and education systems of Belarus, as well as AI users from CIS countries. In total, the surveys covered over 200 respondents.

When analyzing the obtained material, the author’s practical experience as part of the EC of the Belarusian Medical Academy of Postgraduate Education (BelMAPO) and the Committee on Bioethics of the Republic of Belarus (CBRB) was taken into account, which allowed for the comparison of regulatory requirements, international recommendations, and real expert practices.

Overall, the analysis of the obtained data and practices has allowed us to identify the most relevant areas for updating the activities of ECs in the context of open science development, the use of AI tools, and the realities of interdisciplinary research.

The methodological foundation of the interdisciplinary research conducted was based on systemic and comparative approaches, which allowed for the examination of the transformation of EC activities in the context of open science and digitalization of research practices. Methods of systemic and comparative analysis, sociological methods of interviewing and surveying, as well as elements of statistical processing of empirical results were used. This approach effectively harmonized the regulatory, expert, and empirical dimensions of the study, establishing the basis for actionable insights into future strategic paths for the EC.

RESULTS

Considering new tasks and challenges presented by open science to EC, it is necessary to determine the main directions for improving their work, which essentially expand the scope of responsibility, the understanding of expertise, and the actual significance of ECs in modern society.

One of the most complex issues in the activities of the EC today is the examination and support of research conducted using AI. Given the current scientific landscape and the wide use of AI, EC members must routinely evaluate research protocols that use artificial intelligence for data processing, analysis, selection, synthesis, and repurposing. Concurrently, it is becoming increasingly evident that existing knowledge and skills within biomedicine and traditional bioethics are insufficient for a comprehensive evaluation of such projects. This stems not only from the novelty of the technologies themselves, but also from the fact that AI is fundamentally altering the logic of scientific inquiry. It transforms data acquisition methodologies, evaluation criteria, decision-making procedures, and standards for publication transparency.

Under these conditions, a transition is necessary from a fragmented assessment of isolated risks to a holistic framework centered on adherence to the ethical principles of AI deployment in research. Such a system should rest on the core values and principles of biomedical ethics such as respect for the person, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice. At the same time, reviewers must account for fundamental AI principles like responsibility and controllability. These are achieved by ensuring transparency, interpretability, safety, and explainability, which directly address the unique challenges of the digital environment.

Furthermore, the framework must incorporate essential individual and societal benchmarks for AI deployment, specifically the core principles of justice and trust. As part of this study, we collaborated with colleagues to design a framework of ethical principles for AI utilization (fig. 1) [10], which functions as a practical tool for both researchers and ethics committees reviewing AI-driven projects. This proposed system of principles allows ECs to assess whether using AI in a specific study is ethical and permissible, helping them detect potential risks during the initial design phases.

Based on the scheme proposed above, a checklist has been developed for the ethical analysis of AI use in research, intended for both self-assessment of researchers and the work of EC members. Answers to the checklist questions allow for an assessment of whether key principles of ethical AI application have been considered, including whether the goals of technology use have been defined, algorithmic solutions have been described, data processing transparency has been ensured, error control and discrimination prevention mechanisms have been provided, and the boundaries of the research team’s responsibility are clear. For EC members, the checklist serves as a tool for structured expertise, helping to compare submitted projects not only with traditional bioethical criteria but also with the new requirements of digital science [9].

Assessing the use of data and databases represents a new area of focus for ECs examining AI systems. In research using AI, data often becomes the central object of ethical evaluation, as the scientific validity of the results and the protection of research participants’ rights depend on its quality, origin, representativeness, and usage policies. In this regard, modern data management models, in particular the “FAIR — CARE — TRUST” model, are of fundamental importance. The FAIR principles guide data to be Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable; CARE emphasizes Collective Benefit, Accountability, Respect for Indigenous Peoples, and Ethics in data, especially concerning community data; TRUST focuses on Transparency, Responsibility, User-orientation, Sustainability, and Trustworthy Technologies [11, 12]. When combined, these approaches allow for a transition from a narrowly technical understanding of data to its ethical, legal, and social comprehension [13].

Along with this, one should also consider the already classic requirements for data quality, which remain relevant in the context of open science. For instance, the classic ALCOA 1 principles dictate that data must be attributable, legible, contemporaneous, original, and accurate [14]. These criteria are especially paramount when evaluating projects where data is reused, aggregated from diverse sources, or utilized as the foundation for algorithmic processing. Consequently, ECs must evaluate not only the research project itself but also the complete data lifecycle encompassing acquisition, analysis, storage, dissemination, and prospective reuse.

The phenomenon of data visitation requires dedicated attention from ECs within the framework of open science. Data visitation refers to rationally organized and controlled access to data for the purposes of inspection, verification, re-analysis, and potential secondary use within agreed-upon ethical and legal conditions. For ECs, this implies the necessity of understanding how data can be made available for scientific verification without compromising confidentiality, participant autonomy, and statutory restrictions. Furthermore, it requires insight into how data access regimes are structured, anonymization algorithms are executed, transfer restriction mechanisms are implemented, and rules for data reuse are defined.

The examination of scientific publications based on the use of AI is no less complex for ECs. In modern conditions, publications can no longer be considered a neutral conclusion to research; it must reflect how AI was used, what data was involved, how errors were controlled, who is responsible for the conclusions, and how research integrity was ensured. This implies new requirements for reporting, authorship transparency, disclosure of AI tool roles, and accurate description of data analysis procedures.

Thus, the examination of research using AI systems prioritizes not only the updates to the professional competence of EC members but also the development of comprehensive methodological recommendations covering AI operation principles, data management, data visitation, publication requirements, etc. Under these conditions, systematic training of EC members and implementation of practical tools are necessary to conduct ethical reviews of modern digital research at a qualitatively new level.

Another crucial priority and new direction in the ethical review of research within the framework of open science is the analysis of Community engagement in research as a necessary element of modern biomedical practice. This goes beyond simple, formal contact with participants. It requires genuinely engaging individuals and involving the communities impacted by the project in discussions about its goals, risks, methods, and outcomes, as well as in the overall ethical and social review process.

For biomedical research, involvement of populations that possess both a strong interest and the highest possible degree of personal objectivity is of paramount importance. Biomedical studies require communities that understand the long-term impacts of research and hold vital local knowledge; without their engagement, a scientific project risks being both methodologically flawed and ethically incomplete. Under these circumstances, the EC evaluating the research both prior to its initiation and following its completion is required to do as follows:
- to assess whether the project incorporates mechanisms for community engagement;
- to check whether the community participation is reduced to mere formal notification;
- to find out how the research design takes into account the interests and vulnerabilities of certain groups;
- to analyze whether the communities are involved at the stage of planning, conducting and distributing the research outcomes;
- to recommend using feedback forms to communicate with participants and communities;
- to ensure that the research results are shared ethically, especially when the findings might affect the reputation, access to resources, or social status of specific groups [15].

Thus, Community engagement of communities turns into a new element of research ethics and another area of responsibility for the EC. Members of ethical structures translate the standards of open science thereby facilitating the transition of scientific research toward the establishment of authentic mechanisms for societal dialogue and feedback. The EC transcend formal protocol control, serving as institutions that support the shift from declarative participation to true collaboration in scientific research. A significant trend in the activity of EC consists in analyzing ethical standards and principles of scientific activity, as well as their implementing in the conducted research. Compliance with the ethical standards of science has always been part of the expertise of projects. However, by focusing primarily on research risks, benefits, and participant information, EC have often left broader questions of adherence to general ethical principles of scientific activity outside their scope of interest. Since the publication of R. Merton’s classical work, which defined the standards of research activity [16], the principles of the ethos of science have undergone significant changes; in particular, they now prioritize scientific integrity and honesty, implement standards of scientific skepticism and ethical review [17], and supplement modern research ethics with the ethical values of open science, namely transparency, reproducibility, inclusivity, etc.

Modern research on scientific integrity demonstrates that violations of the scientific ethos are increasingly linked not only to direct forms of research misconduct, such as plagiarism, but also to more “subtle” and difficult-to-detect practices: the formalization of peer review procedures, insufficient transparency in data analysis, the improper use of digital tools, and the blurring of responsibility among researchers, consultants, and algorithmic systems. Thus, it is essential to shift from the specific check of whether the protocol corresponds to the official requirements to a more comprehensive estimation of how well the project truly adheres to the principles of honesty, openness, verifiability, and accountability.

In this regard, EC should act not as the bodies of preliminary approval of research, but also as experts setting the framework for maintaining a research culture. The suggested system of ethical principles of building a modern science allows to connect the basic standards of biomedical ethics with the principles of open science and modern requirements of scientific ethos including additional rules of working with AI systems, data, publications, etc. (fig. 2) [18]. The scheme can be used by the EC as a value guideline when evaluating projects, especially in cases involving complex digital and interdisciplinary research.

It is essential to consider that when EC members conduct ethical reviews to evaluate whether a scientist’s activities comply with core research ethics principles, they require specialized training in the humanities. This involves not only one-time briefings and recommendations, but also regular training, ongoing consultations with experts, and thematic webinars dedicated to research integrity, open science, publication ethics, and proper data management. Through this approach, the EC fulfills both a supervisory and an educational purpose, actively guiding researchers to comply with contemporary standards of scientific ethics.

Finally, another emerging area of activity for ECs or rather, the formation of new functionality and development scope, involves expanding their area of responsibility beyond biomedical practices to encompass all research related to the study of humans, nature, and society. The traditional model of the EC was formed around clinical and biomedical research, where the central focus was the protection of the participant’s physical and mental well-being. Yet in the context of open science, the borders separating medicine, sociology, computer science, psychology, and ecology are growing shifting and increasingly blurred. Therefore, research that is not formally classified as medical may nonetheless involve sensitive data, vulnerable groups, social risks, and issues of equity.

For example, a project that analyzes large volumes of digital footprints left by social media users to predict depression, anxiety, or suicide risk can no longer be considered purely technical or sociological. This type of research raises a complex array of ethical questions, including consent for data usage, privacy boundaries, the risk of stigmatization, algorithmic bias, and the potential for interfering in a person’s life based on data misinterpretation. In this case, the EC approval and oversight are absolutely necessary, even if the study is not conducted in a clinical setting and is not directly related to traditional medicine. Similarly, this applies to research in neurotechnology, genetic database analysis, environmental projects impacting local communities, and social research involving sensitive personal data.

Thus, ECs in modern science can increasingly be viewed as universal institutions for the ethical correction of research activities. Their task is not to replace the scientific community, but to ensure that new forms of research, regardless of the scientific discipline, correspond to the values of respect for persons, fairness, responsibility, and transparency. In this sense, the expansion of ECs beyond biomedicine is not expansion for expansion’s sake: it is a necessary condition for the ethical sustainability of open science. This trend should become a system-forming element in modern science. Focusing on the existing medical ECs, it is necessary to create similar structures in humanitarian, natural science, and even technical knowledge (for example, in the fields of pedagogy, psychology, sociology, bioinformatics, etc.). Such structures can be permanently established in universities, at academies of sciences, and in research laboratories, etc., focusing primarily on ethical education and consultation for researchers, as well as on the humanistic evaluation of contemporary scientific projects. Bioethical education is important for both young researchers and the general public, as trust in science largely depends on how well the principles of its ethical organization are understood by society.

CONCLUSION

Having examined the distinctive aspects of the EC activities within open science, the requirements outlined by its members for national-scale coordination, and their main lines of effort, the following conclusions can be formulated:

  1. Modern ECs are inevitably moving beyond traditional biomedical expertise, evolving into a vital institution that supports all research concerning humans, nature, and society within the context of open science, digitalization, and expanding interdisciplinary approaches.
  2. The ethical review of projects utilizing AI systems requires the EC not only to update their knowledge but also to develop a comprehensive framework for working with AI, including assessing data quality and origin, transparency of algorithmic decisions, researcher accountability, and proper publication of results.
  3. Data handling issues in modern research should be considered by the EC as a separate ethical block. The FAIR, CARE, and TRUST principles, as well as the classic data quality benchmarks formulated in the ALCOA framework, are of paramount importance; integrating them allows for a clear connection between scientific integrity, requirements of open science, and responsible data use.
  4. The patterns of open science mandate that ECs actively engage society in research; this should be conceptualized not as token communication, but as the genuine inclusion of communities in debating research objectives, potential risks, methodological design, and dissemination of findings. This is especially important in biomedical projects, where communities can act not only as an object but also as a significant subject of the scientific process.
  5. ECs should play a more active educational role, extending beyond project evaluation to include advising young scientists and research teams on research ethics norms, as well as disseminating research integrity practices. Such activity contributes to the cultivation of a culture of responsible science and a reduction in formalism during ethical reviews.
  6. To implement the new functions of the EC, systemic training of its members, preparation of practical guidelines, and development of permanent consultative formats of work are necessary. This is especially relevant for AI research, projects involving data visitation and reuse, and interdisciplinary studies that extend beyond biomedicine.
  7. EC development should shift from a predominantly permissive model toward a model of expert-consultative and educational support for science.

___________

1 ALCOA is an acronym describing the core principles of data integrity within the pharmaceutical quality system.

КОММЕНТАРИИ (0)